Costco now offers a 'humongous' pumpkin pie, and the price will make your jaw drop
Sarah Margaret Sandlin, a content creator in North Carolina, shows off Costco's latest autumn offering, a "humongous" pumpkin pie that only costs $5.99.
As families head into the holiday season, many shoppers assume warehouse clubs and big-box stores are the smartest places to save — but consumer experts warn that jumbo purchases can quietly drain your budget.
"Buying in bulk seems like the smart move when trying to afford food during this expensive season, but it can backfire," Andrea Woroch, a money-saving expert based in California, told Fox News Digital.
AFFORDABLE MENUS AND SMALLER PORTIONS NEED TO BE OFFERED BY RESTAURANTS, CELEBRITY CHEF INSISTS
Key grocery staples such as produce and dairy are pricier than last year, so experts say shoppers should be selective, starting with these five items that are rarely a good deal in bulk.
1. Fresh produce
Fruits and vegetables like berries, avocados, bananas and spinach rarely survive long enough for smaller households to get their money's worth, savvy shoppers say.
Produce and dairy often go bad quickly when purchased in bulk. (Stephanie Keith/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
"You're not going to go through that food fast enough to have it at its freshest, unless you're having guests," Trae Bodge, a New Jersey-based shopping expert and brand strategist, told Fox News Digital. "You can certainly break these rules a little bit during the holidays."
Shoppers should avoid one especially tempting bulk item — pre-cut fruit salad — unless it's being served immediately, she said.
TOP AMERICAN PASTA BRANDS READY TO TAKE OVER AMID TARIFFS ON IMPORTED PRODUCTS
"You will get a much better deal buying the whole produce in smaller quantities and doing the cutting yourself … Those pre-made fruit salads are marked up by around 100%," she said.
2. Milk and yogurt
Milk is often priced low at regular grocery stores as a "loss leader," Woroch said, meaning the store takes a hit to get you in the door.
So buying it in bulk doesn't save much, and it may spoil before you drink it.
Bread, yogurt and other perishables may cost more than they save. (Stephanie Keith/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
Yogurt is another item that looks economical but turns quickly.
"Yogurt can go bad in a few weeks," Woroch said. "Look for deals on individual containers instead."
3. Bread and baked goods
Bread often goes stale or moldy long before families can finish the giant twin- or triple-packs sold at warehouse stores.
COSTCO SHOPPERS RAVE OVER SEASONAL PIE THAT'S NEARLY 4 POUNDS AND LESS THAN $6
"Bread can spoil quickly, and you can find plenty of deals rotating on different types of bread at your local grocery store or big-box retailers without having to worry about eating it all before it gets moldy," Woroch said.
Freezing is an option, but only if you have the space.
4. Bulk spices, rice and olive oil
These pantry staples sound like a safe bulk buy, but they lose quality faster than most people realize.
Experts warn that some pantry staples can lose freshness quickly. (iStock)
"Things like spices, brown rice and olive oil are not at their best after about six months," Bodge said.
Other pantry items, however, may be worth it, Woroch said.
TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ
"I'm a fan of buying pantry staples in bulk, especially around the holidays when I'm cooking and baking more. ... Just make sure to use airtight containers," she added.
"Flour and sugar are single-ingredient goods, so a name brand can't produce it any differently than the store brand, so save yourself money."
5. Chips, crackers and nuts
Lots of snacks can go stale soon after opening, but some are packaged in a way that helps keep them fresh for longer.
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER
"If you want to buy in bulk, look for crackers sold in 'fresh' stacks, which means they have smaller packaged crackers inside the box to preserve freshness," Woroch said.
"Otherwise, look for discounts on regular-size bags from big-box stores to score the best bargain."
Experts say splitting bulk buys and sticking to store brands can help save money. (David Paul Morris/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
Buying nuts and seeds in bulk can also backfire because oxygen causes them to lose freshness and many of them actually need refrigeration to stay fresh.
Plus, the snack aisle is frequently marked down anyway, experts note.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE LIFESTYLE STORIES
Splitting oversized hauls with family or neighbors, breaking down giant gift baskets from warehouse clubs, stocking up on budget-friendly alcohol and leaning on store brands and savings apps can help shoppers stretch their dollars.
Avoid the free samples, which will often tempt you into buying more, Bodge said.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
"If you end up tossing a third of what you buy, you didn't save anything," she added.
Fox News Lifestyle
A look at the top-trending stories in food, relationships, great outdoors and more.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
